The blog that exploded
Skip to contentBlack Hat Information Architecture: the Ryanair way
It looks like there's something like Black Hat Information Architecture, that is implementing an on purpose bad IA to cheat on your user, and gain some money playing on your user distraction or misunderstanding of the rules.
You probably know Ryan Air a low cost airline operating mainly in Europe, as quite all low cost airlines (depending on the Country they operate/advertise, as in some place now things are changing) they advertise flight at extremely low prices (as low as 0.1 Euro) without putting too much emphasis on the airport/security/fuel surcharge. The resulting fare might rise to tens or hundreds of Euros even if the starting (read advertised) price is just cents. We are no dummy anymore, and already know the trick. That's fine.
Online booking
The fact is the same attitude is used during the online booking process. The Contact page of the whole booking process is where the IA bad practice is deployed. The Passenger Detail part of this page, the first step, is where you should put your name and surname and where you should select how many bags you would like to board. The selection could be made using a combo menu, listed items are:
- 0 Bags - Online Checkin/Priority Boarding
- 1 Bag
- 2 Bags
- 3 Bag
- 4 Bags
- 5 Bags
The fact here is that selecting the first item, 0 Bags - Online Checkin/Priority Boarding, you are requested to pay 6 Euros for the chance to board first, that is pass the passport and boarding control before other travelers just after families with small children. Low fare airlines do not provide numbered seats, travelers are served on a first-come/first-served basis. The point here is, as I'm a used to flight with Ryanair, it's not unusual that even with this priority boarding you pass the check just after other passengers depending on airport personnel attitude. Also you usually have to wait for the shuttle to pick you up and take you at the airplane and then the rush for the seats starts all over from the beginning no matter the priority boarding.
But that's not the point of this post, the point here is there's no easy accessible option to just select 0 bags but no priority boarding. That is, the smart guys at Ryanair didn't put the option on that very same combo menu, they just put it a remove linked text underneath. There are quite some chances the standard user (and this happened to me as well while booking a flight for my girlfriend) won't see that text and pay the 6 Euros for the priority boarding (I'm using the italic for priority boarding to stress the sarcasm) even if she really doesn't care. It's like the smart guys putting Google AdWords has masked part of a text. The following images display the above mentioned page, the second image is bigger and could break this blog layout but this is done to make you read the text.
There's really no need not to have a 0 Bags - No Priority Boarding item on the list, a part obviously to cheat on the user and make her pay for a service she doesn't want.
Play the Ryanair game, spot the remove text
Click the following image for a better, clean view
Tags for this post
Search this blog
Subscribe to the feed!
What is this RSS thing? For help on subscribing and more options, or to subscribe to a particular category, please have a look at: RSS feed how to.
Aggregate Me!
Support Civil Liberties and Human Rights
Support EFF and Amnesty International, visit their web sites and find out how you can help.



I think you're mistaken. If
Well, it seems I'm not the only one to think that way...
Dear Chris, the news is of November this year, and was widely reported by major newspapers:
EU calls time on misleading airline ticket websites
Clampdown on airline ticket websites that use misleading advertising and unfair practices to lure buyers into booking flights.
Free or cut-price tickets that turn out not to be available; airport taxes and other hidden costs; insurance that's automatically added unless you opt out – these are just some of the unlawful practices the EU has found on over 50% of the websites checked.
European airlines could be force to close websites
European airlines could be force to close websites
The results of the investigation to be published on Wednesday and obtained by Reuters says "over 50 percent of all Web sites showed irregularities, in particular relating to price indications, contract terms and clarity of proposed conditions.
200 European airlines' Web sites in peril
More than half show irregularities in price, terms and clarity of conditions
Over 200 European Web sites selling airline tickets, including many run by leading airlines, mislead consumers and will be shut down if they fail to improve, the European Union's consumer chief said on Wednesday.
Airline websites caught misleading on ticket prices
Airline websites caught misleading on ticket prices.
Hundreds of websites selling air tickets could be breaking the law by adding extra charges to advertised prices, an investigation in the European Union has found.
Post new comment